Peanut Butter Cups

Milk Chocolate Style

Peanut Butter Cups packed with peanut butter and draped in our rich & creamy milk chocolate – without the calories and sugar?! Seemingly impossible, but we’ve made it possible and this treat will take your taste bud for a ride.

Want to try it free?

$24.99 / 6-Pack
$45.99 / 12-Pack
Regular price
$24.99
Sale price
$24.99
Regular price
Sold out
Unit price
translation missing: en.general.accessibility.unit_price_separator 
/ 6 pack
1/2 the calories
1/4 the sugar
keto approved
2g net carb per serving
smooth & creamy

INGREDIENTS

Allulose, EPG (Modified Plant-Based Oil), Peanut Butter (Roasted Peanuts), Soluble Corn Fiber, Palm Kernel Oil, Nonfat Dry Milk, Sugar, Cocoa Powder, Peanut Flour, Sea Salt, Sunflower Lecithin, Natural Flavor, Medium Chain Triglycerides (MCT)

CONTAINS: Milk, Peanuts

NUTRITION

Peanut Butter Cups NUTRITION

US VS THEM

CALORIES
50
115
90
100
SUGAR (G)
2
8
<1
10

On a per gram basis, based on a 20g serving

White Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups
New!

White Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups

White Chocolate Style

Regular price
from $4.16
per pack
Sale price
from $4.16
Regular price
Unit price
translation missing: en.general.accessibility.unit_price_separator 
Peanut Butter Madness

Peanut Butter Madness

Peanut Butter Style

Sold out

Peanut Butter Madness

Peanut Butter Style

Regular price
from $4.99
per pack
Sale price
from $4.99
Regular price
Unit price
translation missing: en.general.accessibility.unit_price_separator 
Sold out
Peanut Butter Cups

Peanut Butter Cups

Milk Chocolate Style

Best Seller

Peanut Butter Cups

Milk Chocolate Style

Regular price
from $4.16
per pack
Sale price
from $4.16
Regular price
Unit price
translation missing: en.general.accessibility.unit_price_separator 
Dark Peanut Butter Cups

Dark Peanut Butter Cups

Dark Chocolate Style

New!

Dark Peanut Butter Cups

Dark Chocolate Style

Regular price
from $4.16
per pack
Sale price
from $4.16
Regular price
Unit price
translation missing: en.general.accessibility.unit_price_separator 
Sea Salt Extra Dark

Sea Salt Extra Dark

Dark Chocolate Style

Sea Salt Extra Dark

Dark Chocolate Style

Regular price
from $4.99
per bar
Sale price
from $4.99
Regular price
Unit price
translation missing: en.general.accessibility.unit_price_separator 
Almond Dark

Almond Dark

Dark Chocolate Style

Best Seller

Almond Dark

Dark Chocolate Style

Regular price
from $4.99
per bar
Sale price
from $4.99
Regular price
Unit price
translation missing: en.general.accessibility.unit_price_separator 
Cookies & Cream

Cookies & Cream

White Chocolate Style

Best Seller

Cookies & Cream

White Chocolate Style

Regular price
from $4.99
per bar
Sale price
from $4.99
Regular price
Unit price
translation missing: en.general.accessibility.unit_price_separator 
Best of the Best Pack

Best of the Best Pack

6-Pack Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups +
6-Pack Sea Salt Extra Dark Bar
The Best of The Best Variety Pack combines two of our most popular items, Sea Salt Extra Dark Chocolate & Peanut Butter Cups, into one exciting sampler pack for $5 off. Get a chance to try our milk & dark chocolate with these two top-rated items.

Whether you’re looking for a low-calorie snack, shopping on a low-sugar, low-carb or keto-friendly diet or simply want a healthy chocolate treat, Gatsby Chocolate bars & peanut butter cups are perfect for you!
144 Reviews

Peanut Butter Cups & Sea Salt Extra Dark Bar

Best of the Best Pack

Peanut Butter Cups & Sea Salt Extra Dark Bar

From $4.16 Per Unit

Dark Chocolate Sampler

Dark Chocolate Sampler

6-Pack Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups +
6-Pack Sea Salt Extra Dark Bar
For all you dark chocolate lovers out there, The Dark Chocolate Sampler combines two of our most popular items, Sea Salt Extra Dark Chocolate & Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups, into one exciting sampler pack. Get a chance to try our dark chocolate in both bars & cups for $5 off!

Whether you’re looking for a low-calorie snack, shopping on a low-sugar, low-carb or keto-friendly diet or simply want a healthy chocolate treat, Gatsby Chocolate bars & peanut butter cups are perfect for you!
122 Reviews

Dark Chocolate PB Cups & Sea Salt Extra Dark Bar

Dark Chocolate Sampler

Dark Chocolate PB Cups & Sea Salt Extra Dark Bar

From $4.16 Per Unit

PB Cups Sampler

PB Cups Sampler

6-Pack Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups +
6-Pack Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups
Can't get enough cups? The Peanut Butter Cup Sampler combines our two decadent cup flavors, Milk & Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups, into one exciting sampler pack for $5 off. Get a chance to try our dark chocolate in both bars & cups!

Whether you’re looking for a low-calorie snack, shopping on a low-sugar, low-carb or keto-friendly diet or simply want a healthy chocolate treat, Gatsby Chocolate bars & peanut butter cups are perfect for you!
152 Reviews

Milk Chocolate & Dark Chocolate PB Cups

PB Cups Sampler

Milk Chocolate & Dark Chocolate PB Cups

From $3.75 Per Unit

Oat Milk Crunch Bar

Oat Milk Crunch Bar

Oat Milk Chocolate Style

Best Seller

Oat Milk Crunch Bar

Oat Milk Chocolate Style

Regular price
from $4.99
per bar
Sale price
from $4.99
Regular price
Unit price
translation missing: en.general.accessibility.unit_price_separator 
Oat Milk Salted Almond

Oat Milk Salted Almond

Oat Milk Chocolate Style

Best Seller

Oat Milk Salted Almond

Oat Milk Chocolate Style

Regular price
from $4.99
per bar
Sale price
from $4.99
Regular price
Unit price
translation missing: en.general.accessibility.unit_price_separator 
Seasonal Candy Cane Crunch

Seasonal Candy Cane Crunch

White Chocolate Style

Best Seller

Seasonal Candy Cane Crunch

White Chocolate Style

Regular price
from $4.99
per bar
Sale price
$4.99
Regular price
Unit price
translation missing: en.general.accessibility.unit_price_separator 

Related Products

Explore the complete Gatsby collection

Product title


/12 PACK

SAVE $5


Customer Reviews

Based on 191 reviews
82%
(156)
7%
(14)
4%
(8)
1%
(2)
6%
(11)
A
Alan Coupland

Flavor and consistency was great - cups were a little small, but were satisfying

R
Rashondra Levarity
Dark chocolate peanut butter cups

These peanut butter cups are some of the best! Drop everything and get you some …. Thank me later 😊

A
Andrew
Made me absolutely sick

Couldn’t digest it at all. It tastes good but I won’t be buying these again.

S
Stephie B.
So good!

I ordered these for my husband actually, because I don't like the traditional orange package PB cups at all, but he does. However, these peanut butter cups are amazing! I love them and I haven't even given a single one to my husband yet.

P
Phillip Albright
Smooth

The cups arrived on time. They also were smooth peanut butter. I did freeze some of my packs of 2 like I would other brands. Let them thaw for 10 minutes and perfection. Will be getting again. I do wish I could mix the packages of 6 for a combo. I like these better than the regular bars . Portion size is perfect.