Cookie Butter Cups

These are really good. Heavy on the white chocolate and very sweet. If you like sweet treats you are going to like these and who doesn’t like only 50 calories.

Not nearly as good as the Peanut Butter Cups, which I love!

I have tried every flavor but this one did not hit the spot. Too much white chocolate, not enough cookie butter and does not taste like cookie butter.

I was sooo excited to see this new flavor of cups! I'm an avid Gatsby fan and tried everything and love a lot of the bars and cups or at least like them enough to reorder once in a while (with my must have items 😊), but these weren't it.
Cookie butter flavor is not that easy, I get it, but there are products out there that taste great. This one, at least for me, not so much. While I love the white chocolate (please, please, please offer a white chocolate bar without any add ins!), the 'cookie butter' center doesn't taste right to me. It doesn't taste like cookie butter... more like some nut butter shortly before going bad. You know the taste and smell of 'old' peanuts? That's the vibe I'm getting.
I'm hot unhappy I tried them, because I would have always asked myself if those would have been delicious. But I will definitely not add these to my regular reorder rotation.
Still, please continue surprising us with new flavors! I'll definitely try them at least once 😁