Meet your new favorite chocolate

Products

FILTER PRODUCTS

Products

Type

Flavor

Dietary Needs

Products

Filter:

Type
0 selected Reset
Flavor
0 selected Reset
Dietary Needs
0 selected Reset
Clear all

15 products

Filter and sort

Filter and sort

15 products

Type
Clear
Flavor
Clear
Dietary Needs
Clear
Clear all
Clear all

15 products

    Best of the Best Pack

    Best of the Best Pack

    6-Pack Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups +
    6-Pack Sea Salt Extra Dark Bar
    The Best of The Best Variety Pack combines two of our most popular items, Sea Salt Extra Dark Chocolate & Peanut Butter Cups, into one exciting sampler pack for $5 off. Get a chance to try our milk & dark chocolate with these two top-rated items.

    Whether you’re looking for a low-calorie snack, shopping on a low-sugar, low-carb or keto-friendly diet or simply want a healthy chocolate treat, Gatsby Chocolate bars & peanut butter cups are perfect for you!
    144 Reviews

    Peanut Butter Cups & Sea Salt Extra Dark Bar

    Best of the Best Pack

    Peanut Butter Cups & Sea Salt Extra Dark Bar

    WHAT'S INCLUDED

    From $4.16 Per Unit

    Add to cart ADD
    PB Cups Sampler

    PB Cups Sampler

    6-Pack Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups +
    6-Pack Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups
    Can't get enough cups? The Peanut Butter Cup Sampler combines our two decadent cup flavors, Milk & Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups, into one exciting sampler pack for $5 off. Get a chance to try our dark chocolate in both bars & cups!

    Whether you’re looking for a low-calorie snack, shopping on a low-sugar, low-carb or keto-friendly diet or simply want a healthy chocolate treat, Gatsby Chocolate bars & peanut butter cups are perfect for you!
    152 Reviews

    Milk Chocolate & Dark Chocolate PB Cups

    PB Cups Sampler

    Milk Chocolate & Dark Chocolate PB Cups

    WHAT'S INCLUDED

    From $3.75 Per Unit

    Add to cart ADD
    Dark Chocolate Sampler

    Dark Chocolate Sampler

    6-Pack Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups +
    6-Pack Sea Salt Extra Dark Bar
    For all you dark chocolate lovers out there, The Dark Chocolate Sampler combines two of our most popular items, Sea Salt Extra Dark Chocolate & Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups, into one exciting sampler pack. Get a chance to try our dark chocolate in both bars & cups for $5 off!

    Whether you’re looking for a low-calorie snack, shopping on a low-sugar, low-carb or keto-friendly diet or simply want a healthy chocolate treat, Gatsby Chocolate bars & peanut butter cups are perfect for you!
    122 Reviews

    Dark Chocolate PB Cups & Sea Salt Extra Dark Bar

    Dark Chocolate Sampler

    Dark Chocolate PB Cups & Sea Salt Extra Dark Bar

    WHAT'S INCLUDED

    From $4.16 Per Unit

    Add to cart ADD

    Product title

    /12 PACK

    SAVE $5

    1
    ADD TO CART
  • Almond Dark

    Almond Dark

    Dark Chocolate Style

    Sold out

    Almond Dark

    Dark Chocolate Style

    from $4.99
    per bar
    from $4.99
    Sold out
    Sold out
  • Best of the Best Pack

    Best of the Best Pack

    Peanut Butter Cups & Sea Salt Extra Dark Bar

    Best of the Best Pack

    Peanut Butter Cups & Sea Salt Extra Dark Bar

    from $4.99
    per unit
    Add to cart ADD
  • Buzzfeed Variety Pack

    Buzzfeed Variety Pack

    Sold out

    Buzzfeed Variety Pack

    from $4.99
    per pack
    Sold out
    Sold out
  • Classic Milk

    Classic Milk

    Milk Chocolate Style

    Sold out

    Classic Milk

    Milk Chocolate Style

    from $4.99
    per bar
    from $4.99
    Sold out
    Sold out
  • Cookies & Cream

    Cookies & Cream

    White Chocolate Style

    Sold out

    Cookies & Cream

    White Chocolate Style

    from $4.99
    per bar
    from $4.99
    Sold out
    Sold out
  • Dark Chocolate Sampler

    Dark Chocolate Sampler

    Dark Chocolate PB Cups & Sea Salt Extra Dark Bar

    Dark Chocolate Sampler

    Dark Chocolate PB Cups & Sea Salt Extra Dark Bar

    from $4.99
    per unit
    Add to cart ADD
  • Dark Peanut Butter Cups

    Dark Peanut Butter Cups

    Dark Chocolate Style

    New!

    Dark Peanut Butter Cups

    Dark Chocolate Style

    from $4.16
    per pack
    from $4.16
    Add to cart ADD
  • Gatsby Gems

    Gatsby Gems

    Milk Chocolate Style

    Sold out

    Gatsby Gems

    Milk Chocolate Style

    from $4.16
    per pack
    from $4.16
    Sold out
    Sold out
  • Give Me Everything Variety Pack

    Give Me Everything Variety Pack

    Sold out

    Give Me Everything Variety Pack

    from $4.99
    per unit
    Sold out
    Sold out
  • PB Cups Sampler

    PB Cups Sampler

    Milk Chocolate & Dark Chocolate PB Cups

    PB Cups Sampler

    Milk Chocolate & Dark Chocolate PB Cups

    from $4.99
    per unit
    Add to cart ADD
  • Peanut Butter Cups

    Peanut Butter Cups

    Milk Chocolate Style

    Best Seller

    Peanut Butter Cups

    Milk Chocolate Style

    from $4.16
    per pack
    from $4.16
    Add to cart ADD
  • Peanut Butter Cups Gift

    Peanut Butter Cups Gift

    Milk Chocolate Style

    Peanut Butter Cups Gift

    Milk Chocolate Style

    from $4.99
    per pack
    $0.00
    Add to cart ADD
  • Peanut Butter Madness

    Peanut Butter Madness

    Peanut Butter

    New!

    Peanut Butter Madness

    Peanut Butter

    from $4.99
    per pack
    from $4.99
    Add to cart ADD
  • Sea Salt Extra Dark

    Sea Salt Extra Dark

    Dark Chocolate Style

    Sea Salt Extra Dark

    Dark Chocolate Style

    from $4.99
    per bar
    from $4.99
    Add to cart ADD
  • White Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups

    White Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups

    White Chocolate Style

    New!

    White Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups

    White Chocolate Style

    from $4.16
    per pack
    from $4.16
    Add to cart ADD